|
Post by martinw8686 on Jan 13, 2023 22:21:17 GMT
I grew up adoring Ghostbusters, Groundhog Day, Scrooged and Stripes, so in recent years I've found it troubling to hear of his behind the scenes behaviour, initially I brushed of comments from Harald Ramis and Richard Dreyfus as character clashes with an eccentric seeking to improve his craft.
I've read more complaints today, some from Geena Davis in particular that paint Bill Murray as a really toxic and mean spirited individual. There appear to be many stories of Bill being an all round arsehole and also a bit of a creep with women. As recent as 2021 he was suspended from a film for behaviour towards a young female co-star.
With so many stories from co-stars, who I'm inclined to believe it seems the man is utterly toxic, it rather spoils the legacy of those films I loved growing up.
I realise for some it's simply a matter of enjoying the performance and not thinking about the actor but I do feel by watching his films I'm condoning a bully, for every laugh I give, I'm validating this mans poor treatment of others he hurt behind the scenes. I'm seriously considering never watching his films again, just as I will never watch a Woody Allen or Roman Polanski film again.
I'm wondering what others think,can you let go his poor behaviour? Are there other actors you have boycotted?
I also love the film LA Confidential but Kevin Spacey is another actor that makes me feel morally compromised.
|
|
|
Post by masterdoctor on Jan 13, 2023 23:07:45 GMT
My opinion on separating art from the artist is that it's an individual thing, and ultimately the choice of choosing to consume that media or not is something that will vary per person, which is ok, it's a spectrum. For example, J.K Rowling is a horribly transphobic person and continues to argue in bad faith against allowing Trans people to simply exist safely. For me, that kills any desire to watch or read Harry Potter or anything else she profits off of. However, I never really cared for Harry Potter, but so many people did, to the point where it is a defining part of their childhood, so I understand why its not something they are willing to part ways with as a piece of media.
On the flip side, a couple of my favourite movies heavily feature Kevin Spacey, whom I despise, but for those films I have separated him as a person from the art, because I really love those films(Baby Driver and Horrible Bosses). And much like I don't expect people to give up Harry Potter, I don't expect people to separate Kevin Spacey as a person from Kevin Spacey the artist if they don't want to.
|
|
shutupbanks
Castellan
There’s a horror movie called Alien? That’s really offensive. No wonder everyone keeps invading you.
Likes: 5,665
|
Post by shutupbanks on Jan 13, 2023 23:17:50 GMT
There’s an interview with Arsenio Hall from around the time that he and Davis made Quick Change in which Murray is “horsing around” and really getting into Davis’s space. She is laughing it off but is clearly not comfortable with it. Honestly, Ghostbusters is like Ferris Bueller’s Day Off for me: a film I loved when it first came out and which, when watched as an adult, seems to be populated by entitled gits.
Murray has had some great PR working in his favour for ages but a range of “little” incidents appear to be resurfacing or are facing a lot of fresh investigation which doesn’t paint a very nice picture of him. I feel the same way towards Mel Gibson and, like martinw8686, Allen, Spacey and Polanski.
Not an actor, but Jeremy Clarkson is a performer I have disliked and avoided the work of since his suspension from Top Gear for assaulting a producer (his recent comments about Meghan Markle just confirmed that I was right to do so). Thomas Gibson was an actor I enjoyed in Dharma and Greg, and LOVED in Criminal Minds, but the (repeated) behaviour that got him fired from the latter pushed him off my “to watch” list.
I can tolerate petty or abrasive behaviour from people - William Shatner, for example, was egotistical and dismissive of his co-stars in Trek but that was in the service of his career/role in the show - but when it crosses into criminal or abusive behaviour towards other people, I tend to let them go. It hurts, but I’m a fan of so many people and franchises that I can cope with losing one occasionally.
|
|
|
Post by timleschild on Jan 13, 2023 23:19:49 GMT
Another disgusting toxic male.
|
|
|
Post by martinw8686 on Jan 14, 2023 0:33:31 GMT
There’s an interview with Arsenio Hall from around the time that he and Davis made Quick Change in which Murray is “horsing around” and really getting into Davis’s space. She is laughing it off but is clearly not comfortable with it. Honestly, Ghostbusters is like Ferris Bueller’s Day Off for me: a film I loved when it first came out and which, when watched as an adult, seems to be populated by entitled gits. Murray has had some great PR working in his favour for ages but a range of “little” incidents appear to be resurfacing or are facing a lot of fresh investigation which doesn’t paint a very nice picture of him. I feel the same way towards Mel Gibson and, like martinw8686, Allen, Spacey and Polanski. Not an actor, but Jeremy Clarkson is a performer I have disliked and avoided the work of since his suspension from Top Gear for assaulting a producer (his recent comments about Meghan Markle just confirmed that I was right to do so). Thomas Gibson was an actor I enjoyed in Dharma and Greg, and LOVED in Criminal Minds, but the (repeated) behaviour that got him fired from the latter pushed him off my “to watch” list. I can tolerate petty or abrasive behaviour from people - William Shatner, for example, was egotistical and dismissive of his co-stars in Trek but that was in the service of his career/role in the show - but when it crosses into criminal or abusive behaviour towards other people, I tend to let them go. It hurts, but I’m a fan of so many people and franchises that I can cope with losing one occasionally. Yes totally agree with Mel Gibson, that's another tricky one because growing up I enjoyed Mad Max and Lethal Weapon. I'm also totally with you on Jeremy Clarkson, I find him to be an entitled bully, his politics are extremely questionable and he's got away with racism, homophobia and misogyny for far too long. His defenders will tell you his comments are made with humour and to complain is political correctness gone mad, the Megan Markle comments were way way too far. I read something a few weeks ago about Clarkson and Eddie Izzard that upset me, apparently Eddie Izzard was mentioned on Who Wants to be a Millionaire and Eddie now prefers to be known as "She", I believe she is identifying as a woman full time after previously having boy mode and girl mode, Clarkson made a crass comment about refering to Eddie as "it", I've read this story second hand but can quite believe Clarkson would be that intolerant. I don't expect actors and TV personalities to be saints, but there are limits. I'd be a hypocrite not to mention that Tom Baker had a reputation for being difficult and upsetting co-stars and production members, it's nice to see him own it though and that he now has a much better working relationship with the team at Big Finish. Time is a great leveller, I can forgive a lot if people can take responsibility for their actions and seek to be a better person going forward, some apologies are genuine (well outside of politics). I hope one day J K Rowling can realise her views are outdated, intolerant and transphobic, I'd much rather she experience some personal growth than for her to remain the poster child for transphobia. Of course there are actions that I believe to be irredeemable, step forward Woody Allen and Roman Polanski, I find it shocking that not so long ago many Hollywood actors lobbied on behalf of Polanski as if there had been a miscarriage of justice, he openly admits his sexual assault of a child. Sorry I digress, I'm done watching Bill Murray. I may be able to watch Kevin Spacey in films like Baby Driver because he's not the star, it would be a shame to write off a wonderful film that was made before the public were aware of his sexual assaults. I do believe strongly that no one is above the law and that sometimes boycotting a performer is the best way to ensure there are consequences to unacceptable behaviour, unfortunately we live in a world where they elite few can use their finances to escape justice or get lesser sentences.
|
|
|
Post by Digi on Jan 14, 2023 1:11:14 GMT
I think it's been fairly well known for a long time that Bill Murray is a bit of a jerk, hasn't it? Like Chevy Chase, and a lot of others. Comedians in general seem to be pretty damaged people who aren't great humans when they're offstage/not in front of the camera. Even someone who seems as amiable as Conan O'Brien does; I thought he came off as a needy, insecure jerk in that 'Legally Prohibited from Being Funny' documentary they did about his standup during the time between the Tonight Show debacle and his premiere on TBS. And he was always one of my top favourite late night hosts.
Kind of part and parcel of a large percentage of comedians that many people enjoy, honestly. Down to each viewer what they'll choose to overlook...
|
|
|
Post by martinw8686 on Jan 14, 2023 1:41:07 GMT
For me, the Bill Murray thing has tipped over from just being a jerk, the fact that Geena Davies still gets the shakes when recalling her encounters with him speaks volumes, I get really uncomfortable when I hear of men bullying women.
My Wife is terrified of her ex husband, they have to speak occasionally because of my step daughter, he's a manipulative bully with a cruel temper, he was never physically violent but he would shout at full volume right in her face and regularly make cruel and belittling comments, he presents totally different to the outside world and to this day my Wife feels vilified for leaving him. It troubles me that bullying can go under the radar in domestic and working life, it appears to me that Bill Murray and others like him have only recently had a light shone on to their unacceptable behaviour.
I guess at the end of the day it comes down to the individual how they feel about the behaviour of performers, I think the Bill Murray thing just touched a nerve with me, as I can see similarities to the way my wife's ex behaves.
|
|
|
Post by whiskeybrewer on Jan 18, 2023 16:21:47 GMT
With Bill Murray, the only way for me to separate the art from the artist is that many of his films are Ensemble pieces. So for that i can focus on the other members of the ensemble.
is it easy? not always, but it works for the most part
|
|
|
Post by martinw8686 on Jan 18, 2023 20:36:24 GMT
With Bill Murray, the only way for me to separate the art from the artist is that many of his films are Ensemble pieces. So for that i can focus on the other members of the ensemble. is it easy? not always, but it works for the most part I'm with you on ensemble casts, as I don't like to let one bad apple spoil the work of the whole cast. It's more movies like Groundhog Day where Bill Murray leads the whole film, shame it's a great film but I just can't see past what a massive arsehole the man is. It's clear for me with Woody Allen and Roman Polanski, both sex offenders, therefore I won't go anywhere near anything their involved in. I'd say the same for Kevin Spacey but he's had small roles in some amazing films like Baby Driver, Seven and LA Confidential so I do try to separate the art from the artist with those films.
|
|