Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2017 0:36:20 GMT
Hey everyone,
Something which has always bugged me about Genesis of The Daleks is The Doctor's decision not to end The Daleks. More that The Daleks are biological, incapable of escaping their programming, but what about The Kaleds? Horrible bigots that they were, they didn't want to intentionally turn their descendants into genetic hateful killing machines, in capable of love and happiness. Can the fate of the many really justify such means? What The Kaleds were fighting for was horrific, but resigining them to their fate seems cruel and inhumane and I don't thnk The Doctor's long-term view would ever cover that.
I know Genesis is held as a classic for many (and I'll be buying the new audiobook version in July), but for me, it's always asked questions which Doctor Who could never properly answer, beyond the constriants of tea time.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2017 1:25:06 GMT
An important thing to remember with these kinds of stories is that the characters aren't privy to everything that we as the audience see. It's a common mistake people make like assuming that everyone knows what happened between Luke, Vader and the Emperor on the second Death Star. Characters only know what they have observed.
The Doctor does go back to try and destroy the Daleks, but production has progressed by such a point that when the incubator room is destroyed, it will do little more than delay them. By the end of the last episode, it's less about moralising and more about getting out alive. Locked in Davros's office, they observe the confrontation between the Dalek creator and Gharman that is perpetuated solely for the purpose of identifying who of the survivors is loyal to the development of the Daleks and those who need to be destroyed. Ironically, if Nyder hadn't snuck out at the crucial moment, the Doctor, Sarah and Harry would have been massacred with the rest of the dissenters. If not while Gharman was alive then later when the Daleks turned on their creator and wiped out the rest of the elite.
This is a story where if you are shot, you die. Nothing on Skaro will stop that and staying around to try and help the unseen majority of Kaleds limits their own chances of survival. The Thals were going to seal the bunker one way or the other and production had extended to the point where virtually every corridor was patrolled by a drone. They catastrophically outnumber them and they are willing to kill. As a civilian, you only really have one choice and that's run. Run before you're killed like everyone else is going to be. It's certainly not altruistic, but it is necessary. The Doctor cannot do a greater good since if he dies there trying to help everyone. As he points out, he cannot save everyone. That's just not possible.
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Apr 3, 2017 4:14:46 GMT
Weren't all of the Kaleds apart from the Elite dead at that point?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2017 5:41:40 GMT
Weren't all of the Kaleds apart from the Elite dead at that point? Double post
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2017 5:42:18 GMT
Weren't all of the Kaleds apart from the Elite dead at that point? I think so. Davros' missile had destroyed the Kaled dome, which was all that was left of them. The only Kaled's left were those working for Davros.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 3, 2017 6:38:41 GMT
Weren't all of the Kaleds apart from the Elite dead at that point? I think so. Davros' missile had destroyed the Kaled dome, which was all that was left of them. The only Kaled's left were those working for Davros. Yes, that's right. Barring a few here and there who (for one reason or another) would have been outside of the radiation dome. Even then, they would have been hunted down by the Daleks on patrol. So, the ultimate victors of the Thal-Kaled War are the Thals themselves with a little vital assistance from Davros. As an aside, I, Davros also points out that the Kaleds' systematic racial purge of the planet lead to the genocides of the Dal and Tharron races. Interestingly, Davros's inspiration for the ultimate name of his creation from the Dal word for "god".
|
|