|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 0:29:33 GMT
On a similiar note - when we get 11th Doctor stories...maybe Amy could mention her parents again. She finally found them and then they seem to have vanished through the crack again Poor Augustus Pond!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2015 0:40:16 GMT
On a similiar note - when we get 11th Doctor stories...maybe Amy could mention her parents again. She finally found them and then they seem to have vanished through the crack again Poor Augustus Pond! For me, that was one of the big oversights of the Eleven era, particularly in light of previous series. How did Amy adjust to a life where her parents were around? Did she have to distance herself from them just to deal? And how did she deal with her resenment towards Aunt Sharon (who probably did the best she could)?
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 0:55:19 GMT
On a similiar note - when we get 11th Doctor stories...maybe Amy could mention her parents again. She finally found them and then they seem to have vanished through the crack again Poor Augustus Pond! For me, that was one of the big oversights of the Eleven era, particularly in light of previous series. How did Amy adjust to a life where her parents were around? Did she have to distance herself from them just to deal? And how did she deal with her resenment towards Aunt Sharon (who probably did the best she could)? OFF TOPIC ALERT Moffat did it again with Rory in Series 7, specifically with Brian Williams. In just a handful of episodes we meet Brian, totally fall in love with him as a charming and doting father, see him stand up to The Doctor about endangering his families lives on reckless adventures, accept that they're going to do it anyway, KILL his kids off and then just not bothered to see how never seeing Rory again impacts him. I don't know if you saw the storyboard sequence that was written for Brian and never shot but its inexcusable not to use it. It's one of the most touching bits of Doctor Who ever. www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWU6XL9xI4kIf there's any doubt about the difference between RTD and Moffat...it's this 4 minute video. Moffat cut it before filming even began but for RTD it would have been the emotional core of the whole epsiode. He would never have disregarded Brian's story
|
|
|
Post by constonks on Oct 28, 2015 1:00:55 GMT
I love the idea of an adventure with the Tenth Doctor and Sylvia. Focusing on Francine could be pretty interesting as well. Maybe the Doctor and Donna could end up at some Jones family function and swan off with Martha for a couple of adventures. I'd like to see a series with Jack and Ten as well. After all, this week Capaldi said he traveled with an immortal named Jack Harkness... And does the Utopia trilogy really count as "traveling"? Oh also. For obvious demographical reasons, the Doctor never appeared on Torchwood but I think Big Finish can remedy that
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 1:05:45 GMT
For me, that was one of the big oversights of the Eleven era, particularly in light of previous series. How did Amy adjust to a life where her parents were around? Did she have to distance herself from them just to deal? And how did she deal with her resenment towards Aunt Sharon (who probably did the best she could)? OFF TOPIC ALERT Moffat did it again with Rory in Series 7, specifically with Brian Williams. In just a handful of episodes we meet Brian, totally fall in love with him as a charming and doting father, see him stand up to The Doctor about endangering his families lives on reckless adventures, accept that they're going to do it anyway, KILL his kids off and then just not bothered to see how never seeing Rory again impacts him. I don't know if you saw the storyboard sequence that was written for Brian and never shot but its inexcusable not to use it. It's one of the most touching bits of Doctor Who ever. www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWU6XL9xI4kIf there's any doubt about the difference between RTD and Moffat...it's this 4 minute video. Moffat cut it before filming even began but for RTD it would have been the emotional core of the whole epsiode. He would never have disregarded Brian's story If I remember correctly, Mark Williams wasn't available to film that. That's not really Moffat's fault.
|
|
|
Post by agentten on Oct 28, 2015 1:09:30 GMT
My wish list would be very long, can't get enough Ten. Right off I'd want:
- Ten and Rose - Appearances by Mickey Smith and Jackie Tyler - Wilfred Mott in any capacity - More of Ten and River - A new Ood story. Oods are good. Love an Ood. - Ten catching up with other previous companions. His adventure with Sarah Jane and K-9 is tremendous fun and Tennant has such great affection for the characters that Ten seems the Doctor to do this with. I suggest he could meet Jo and Tegan for starters. - When a special occasion arrives, I would love a multi Doctor story with Five and Ten. They were so great together; I'm greedy and I want more of it.
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 1:12:32 GMT
OFF TOPIC ALERT Moffat did it again with Rory in Series 7, specifically with Brian Williams. In just a handful of episodes we meet Brian, totally fall in love with him as a charming and doting father, see him stand up to The Doctor about endangering his families lives on reckless adventures, accept that they're going to do it anyway, KILL his kids off and then just not bothered to see how never seeing Rory again impacts him. I don't know if you saw the storyboard sequence that was written for Brian and never shot but its inexcusable not to use it. It's one of the most touching bits of Doctor Who ever. www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWU6XL9xI4kIf there's any doubt about the difference between RTD and Moffat...it's this 4 minute video. Moffat cut it before filming even began but for RTD it would have been the emotional core of the whole epsiode. He would never have disregarded Brian's story If I remember correctly, Mark Williams wasn't available to film that. That's not really Moffat's fault. It's a TINY scene. Could easily have been filmed when Mark was on the show twice as parts with Churchill or Vincent were in previous years. P.S. was entirely forshadowed in Power Of Three and Amy and Rory's departure works nowhere near as well without it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2015 1:16:36 GMT
My wish list would be very long, can't get enough Ten. Right off I'd want: - Ten catching up with other previous companions. His adventure with Sarah Jane and K-9 is tremendous fun and Tennant has such great affection for the characters that Ten seems the Doctor to do this with. I suggest he could meet Jo and Tegan for starters. Jo's kind of locked in with The Death of The Doctor, but perhaps Ten does encounter her after Waters of Mars and doesn't let on to his identity due to his shame at his actions? I appreciate the sentiment of The Gathering (although not Tegan's logic at the end?), but Ten meeting Tegan would be a nice bridge betwen that story and the reveal at The Death of The Doctor. And Tegan telling Ten to shut up would be amusing, but I could see them getting along given how unreserved Ten is, with Tegan bittersweetly mourning her Doctor and deciding not to travel with him again.
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 1:23:43 GMT
I love the idea of an adventure with the Tenth Doctor and Sylvia. Focusing on Francine could be pretty interesting as well. Maybe the Doctor and Donna could end up at some Jones family function and swan off with Martha for a couple of adventures. I'd like to see a series with Jack and Ten as well. After all, this week Capaldi said he traveled with an immortal named Jack Harkness... And does the Utopia trilogy really count as "traveling"? Oh also. For obvious demographical reasons, the Doctor never appeared on Torchwood but I think Big Finish can remedy that I wouldn't like them to use The Doctor in Torchwood. The tone is potentially far too adult on TW (the series had f-bombs dropping all the time in between sex scenes ) I don't think the Beeb's branding team would even allow that. Not for nothing did RTD veto any Doctor involvement on Torchwood but only allow a toned-down TW on Who. The Captain Jack line this week kinda bugged me too. I almost feel like Catherine Tregana forgot Jack wasn't immortal when he was "just" a companion in Series 1 rather than Torchwood leader and credited guest star cause Utopia-Last Of The Timelords is not what I'd call travelling!
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 1:26:26 GMT
My wish list would be very long, can't get enough Ten. Right off I'd want: - Ten catching up with other previous companions. His adventure with Sarah Jane and K-9 is tremendous fun and Tennant has such great affection for the characters that Ten seems the Doctor to do this with. I suggest he could meet Jo and Tegan for starters. Jo's kind of locked in with The Death of The Doctor, but perhaps Ten does encounter her after Waters of Mars and doesn't let on to his identity due to his shame at his actions? I appreciate the sentiment of The Gathering (although not Tegan's logic at the end?), but Ten meeting Tegan would be a nice bridge betwen that story and the reveal at The Death of The Doctor. And Tegan telling Ten to shut up would be amusing, but I could see them getting along given how unreserved Ten is, with Tegan bittersweetly mourning her Doctor and deciding not to travel with him again. I'd quite like a story where The Doctor meets Jamie. Might even give Tennant a chance to crack out his own accent again, a la Tooth And Claw.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2015 1:37:49 GMT
Jo's kind of locked in with The Death of The Doctor, but perhaps Ten does encounter her after Waters of Mars and doesn't let on to his identity due to his shame at his actions? I appreciate the sentiment of The Gathering (although not Tegan's logic at the end?), but Ten meeting Tegan would be a nice bridge betwen that story and the reveal at The Death of The Doctor. And Tegan telling Ten to shut up would be amusing, but I could see them getting along given how unreserved Ten is, with Tegan bittersweetly mourning her Doctor and deciding not to travel with him again. I'd quite like a story where The Doctor meets Jamie. Might even give Tennant a chance to crack out his own accent again, a la Tooth And Claw. Oh, I'd love that ("Stop wavering your hands about and talk properly, you loon!") .
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 1:52:16 GMT
Oh, I'd love that ("Stop wavering your hands about and talk properly, you loon!") . Kinda makes me wish that Tennant got to do the Jamie trilogy that Sixie had.
|
|
|
Post by elkawho on Oct 28, 2015 1:58:33 GMT
I'd like to see River meet Ten again, and have more stories with Rose, Martha, and Jack in addition to Donna. Perhaps not immediately, but at some point I would also like a multi-Doctor story where New Doctors meet Classic Doctors. Yes, that would be fun. The 4th Doctor and the 10th Doctor meeting definitely needs to happen. My dream story. 4 and 10.
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 2:01:48 GMT
Yes, that would be fun. The 4th Doctor and the 10th Doctor meeting definitely needs to happen. My dream story. 4 and 10. It would be a licence to print money for BF as well. The two Docs that always top fan polls.
|
|
|
Post by elkawho on Oct 28, 2015 2:10:31 GMT
David, you and I seem to be on the same wavelength in this thread. I haven't had to post very much because you're saying everything I'm thinking before I get the chance.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2015 2:13:21 GMT
Yes, that would be fun. The 4th Doctor and the 10th Doctor meeting definitely needs to happen. My dream story. 4 and 10. I don't know, there so different. As much as I love Four, he's not the most developed character as much as as he is a personality and it would feel like apples and oranges. It really depends what Big Finish do in the gap between The Well-Mannered War and Season 22. Perhaps, something goes wrong out of the void after The Age of Steel and there they met. In the anywhere. For Four, it's the sadness that his life will end, for Ten, it's a sharp reminder of all that he lost and struggles to gain and an all too brutally reminder of the bad times that come. I think an adventure with Five and Ten in a more traditional vein (it feels inevitable, doesn't it?) might work, particularly to see Five contend in a story filled with Ten era whackiness.
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 2:19:57 GMT
I know they can't do it yet, but I want to see Six and Twelve.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Likes:
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 28, 2015 2:21:18 GMT
I know they can't do it yet, but I want to see Six and Twelve. I don't think Six could surrive!
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 2:22:05 GMT
I know they can't do it yet, but I want to see Six and Twelve. I don't think Six could surrive! I'm not sure if Twelve can either.
|
|
|
Post by idle453 on Oct 28, 2015 2:22:35 GMT
Having just listened to sympathy for the devil, I would like to have the doctor encounter brimmicom-wood.
Also wild like to see ten encounter a master from the old series or at least more traditional than Simms. My oral wild be where the master forces the doctor to relive past events from previous doctors. I think hearing ten having to deal with adric's death or remembering the five doctors would be interesting. I now the logistics would probably never work out.
And just because I have a soft spot for the character, I want to see him meet absalo Daak
Finally I would like to see six encounter ten.
IDLE
|
|