|
Post by dalekbuster523finish on Oct 28, 2015 14:26:17 GMT
10 + Clara They worked so well together in the 50th that bring them together in their own set of adventures would be great. 10 barely interacted with Clara...
|
|
|
Post by dalekbuster523finish on Oct 28, 2015 14:28:49 GMT
Five/Ten and Jenny then we get the whole family connection aha I guess I'd like Martha/Ten adventures too But really Ten/Donna was my number one pick so they can't beat that. Considering they're married in real life, it would be brilliant if they had really awkward flirting between the Doctor and his own daughter!
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 14:33:36 GMT
10 + Clara They worked so well together in the 50th that bring them together in their own set of adventures would be great. Or maybe 10 and a Clara splinter.
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 15:29:07 GMT
I wouldn't like them to use The Doctor in Torchwood. The tone is potentially far too adult on TW (the series had f-bombs dropping all the time in between sex scenes ) I don't think the Beeb's branding team would even allow that. Not for nothing did RTD veto any Doctor involvement on Torchwood but only allow a toned-down TW on Who. The Captain Jack line this week kinda bugged me too. I almost feel like Catherine Tregana forgot Jack wasn't immortal when he was "just" a companion in Series 1 rather than Torchwood leader and credited guest star cause Utopia-Last Of The Timelords is not what I'd call travelling! Key word is "potentially". Audio Torchwood has never been as adult as TV version. Personally I'd prefer five to appear in Torchwood. Six and Seven have stories with the Forge or Countermeasures but Five hasn't had this type of story. We've not had that many BF TW releases to speak about what it is and what it isn't. I wouldn't want to neuter Torchwood's future storytelling by saying it couldn't be as adult as the show just becuase I want Peter Davison in it. I honestly think it's a moot point. The branding team at the Beeb are going to obviously scrutinise the Nu-Who related stuff a lot more than, say, a Jago And Litefoot. And more importantly BF aren't going to rock the apple cart. RTD has spoken time and again about why he wouldn't feature the Doctor in Torchwood. I don't see why he, the BBC and BF would reverse this policy now.
|
|
|
Post by constonks on Oct 28, 2015 15:52:24 GMT
Key word is "potentially". Audio Torchwood has never been as adult as TV version. Personally I'd prefer five to appear in Torchwood. Six and Seven have stories with the Forge or Countermeasures but Five hasn't had this type of story. We've not had that many BF TW releases to speak about what it is and what it isn't. I wouldn't want to neuter Torchwood's future storytelling by saying it couldn't be as adult as the show just becuase I want Peter Davison in it. I honestly think it's a moot point. The branding team at the Beeb are going to obviously scrutinise the Nu-Who related stuff a lot more than, say, a Jago And Litefoot. And more importantly BF aren't going to rock the apple cart. RTD has spoken time and again about why he wouldn't feature the Doctor in Torchwood. I don't see why he, the BBC and BF would reverse this policy now. I guess that's fair. When I said that I was really thinking about how dark and adult some of the other DW releases have been in the past - admittedly not as far as Torchwood but still darker and more adult than the TV show. But you're right. They'd probably stop that.
|
|
|
Post by david on Oct 28, 2015 16:02:09 GMT
We've not had that many BF TW releases to speak about what it is and what it isn't. I wouldn't want to neuter Torchwood's future storytelling by saying it couldn't be as adult as the show just becuase I want Peter Davison in it. I honestly think it's a moot point. The branding team at the Beeb are going to obviously scrutinise the Nu-Who related stuff a lot more than, say, a Jago And Litefoot. And more importantly BF aren't going to rock the apple cart. RTD has spoken time and again about why he wouldn't feature the Doctor in Torchwood. I don't see why he, the BBC and BF would reverse this policy now. I guess that's fair. When I said that I was really thinking about how dark and adult some of the other DW releases have been in the past - admittedly not as far as Torchwood but still darker and more adult than the TV show. But you're right. They'd probably stop that. Well, its just my reading - could be enitrely wrong but even if the Doctor doesn't appear it Torchwood maybe there's scope for a less-adult Torchwood to appear in some Who stories like they did in Journey's End. I just believe that BF will have more set terms on these big licences - and thus less free-reign - than on a lot of their classic series work.
|
|
|
Post by Audio Watchdog on Oct 28, 2015 16:27:32 GMT
Five/Ten and Jenny then we get the whole family connection aha I guess I'd like Martha/Ten adventures too But really Ten/Donna was my number one pick so they can't beat that. Considering they're married in real life, it would be brilliant if they had really awkward flirting between the Doctor and his own daughter! Actually, no. Eww.
|
|
|
Post by charlesuirdhein on Oct 28, 2015 16:29:47 GMT
I DO have an objection (hate saying this because I love the actors) to Niky Wardley and Beth Chalmers being used outside their roles as companions (especially Beth as Raine is still alive and kicking and with soooo much more to tell) in this new set. Yes, one person has appeared outside their companion role before after they played that companion, Jacqueline Hill, but that was intended stunt casting; and others have appeared BEFORE they became companions. I don't know, it's probably nothing but I'd have chosen different actors, despite the fact I'd pay for Beth Chalmers to read a phone book to me.
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 17:01:56 GMT
Five/Ten and Jenny then we get the whole family connection aha I guess I'd like Martha/Ten adventures too But really Ten/Donna was my number one pick so they can't beat that. Considering they're married in real life, it would be brilliant if they had really awkward flirting between the Doctor and his own daughter! That would make much more sense, and be much weirder if it was the other way around (Tennant's daughter playing his wife).
|
|
|
Post by dalekbuster523finish on Oct 28, 2015 17:46:28 GMT
Considering they're married in real life, it would be brilliant if they had really awkward flirting between the Doctor and his own daughter! That would make much more sense, and be much weirder if it was the other way around (Tennant's daughter playing his wife). I don't think it would be weirder than the Doctor flirting with his own daughter personally. You certainly wouldn't expect a father to flirt with his daughter because of how 'wrong' it would seem. Although it could seem a bit distasteful and ruin the character depending how it were to be done. Maybe it could be an older Jenny the Doctor doesn't recognise until its too late?
|
|
|
Post by Bazoolium on Oct 28, 2015 17:53:54 GMT
Someone mentioned the Scorchies, I think they'd work much better with 11. But anyway, what I'd love to see in the 10th Doctor Adventures.
- More River, in Time of Angles 11 says he keeps bumping iinto her. Plenty of room for that to have been 10. - Martha and Donna. Nothing stopping Martha calling the Doctor again. - Solo stories set in the Specials Year - Rose. I'm sure it's only a matter of time.
|
|
|
Post by Audio Watchdog on Oct 28, 2015 18:08:01 GMT
That would make much more sense, and be much weirder if it was the other way around (Tennant's daughter playing his wife). I don't think it would be weirder than the Doctor flirting with his own daughter personally. You certainly wouldn't expect a father to flirt with his daughter because of how 'wrong' it would seem. Although it could seem a bit distasteful and ruin the character depending how it were to be done. Maybe it could be an older Jenny the Doctor doesn't recognise until its too late? No. A thousand times no. Please stop. You don't need to highlight wrong. Older Jenny? No. Yes it is distasteful. Yes it is wrong. Yes it is gross. Please stop talking about it.
|
|
|
Post by jasonward on Oct 28, 2015 18:32:32 GMT
The reason we have an emotional/moral objection to sexual inter-family relationships is because biologically/evolutionary it's a bad idea, it leads to genetic abnormalities and ill health, from a genetic point of view The Doctor and his daughter would be even worse as she's basically a genetic copy of him.
From an intellectual point of view I'm often interested to see things that expose our morals and make us think, or some people at least, but this particular one, is basically fully understood by most people, we don't just hold this moral view without understanding why, for the most part we understand why this moral exists, and what makes it basically a good idea.
As such, having The Doctor flirting with his daughter doesn't achieve anything apart from to revolt those who are revolted and perhaps titillate some others. This doesn't seem a good reason to use it in a story, there loads of things that could do with a mirror holding up to them, things that causing a pause for thought would be useful, but this one? I don't think so.
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 19:10:20 GMT
The reason we have an emotional/moral objection to sexual inter-family relationships is because biologically/evolutionary it's a bad idea, it leads to genetic abnormalities and ill health, from a genetic point of view The Doctor and his daughter would be even worse as she's basically a genetic copy of him. From an intellectual point of view I'm often interested to see things that expose our morals and make us think, or some people at least, but this particular one, is basically fully understood by most people, we don't just hold this moral view without understanding why, for the most part we understand why this moral exists, and what makes it basically a good idea. As such, having The Doctor flirting with his daughter doesn't achieve anything apart from to revolt those who are revolted and perhaps titillate some others. This doesn't seem a good reason to use it in a story, there loads of things that could do with a mirror holding up to them, things that causing a pause for thought would be useful, but this one? I don't think so. Well, its not impossible to do a story that takes an interesting look on the morality of inter-family relationships. I've been reading a lot of Asimov lately, and in one of his robot novels there is a planet where people don't have sex for reproduction anymore, and where people aren't raised with their families anyway. Therefore, only the main character who is from Earth is grossed out when a daughter propositions her father for sex. Most other characters are more shocked that the father said no. In this case, however, it would just be stupid and gross.
|
|
|
Post by dalekbuster523finish on Oct 28, 2015 20:05:37 GMT
- Solo stories set in the Specials Year Yes please. That would be brilliant, especially if set between The Water of Mars and The End of Time with 10 acting all Time Lord Victorious.
|
|
|
Post by icecreamdf on Oct 28, 2015 20:17:35 GMT
- Solo stories set in the Specials Year Yes please. That would be brilliant, especially if set between The Water of Mars and The End of Time with 10 acting all Time Lord Victorious. He stopped acting all Time Lord Victorious once Adelaide killed herself. In between Waters of Mars and End of Time, he should be acting guilty and irresponsible, trying to put off his inevitable trip to the Oodsphere.
|
|
|
Post by dalekbuster523finish on Oct 28, 2015 20:39:33 GMT
Yes please. That would be brilliant, especially if set between The Water of Mars and The End of Time with 10 acting all Time Lord Victorious. He stopped acting all Time Lord Victorious once Adelaide killed herself. In between Waters of Mars and End of Time, he should be acting guilty and irresponsible, trying to put off his inevitable trip to the Oodsphere. Totally disagree and many others online do too from what I have seen. I think there's plenty of scope between Water of Mars and The End of Time for 10 to still be going Time Lord Victorious. Before Steven Moffat showed it in Day of the Doctor, it's clear that Russell T Davies' intention with the Queen Elisabeth 1 reference (despite it being a joke) was to show 10 didn't care about the consequences of his actions and interferences with time any more given that she was always known as the virgin queen.
|
|
|
Post by barnabaslives on Oct 28, 2015 21:31:26 GMT
Oh, let's see... I think stories with Jack, Rose, Mickey and River would all be great. Martha too or else I'd love to hear more from her in UNIT or something. I really wasn't very moved that the Doctor had a daughter (it's not like he was trying) :-) but I will certainly reconsider that after having just finally learned from this thread of her real-life relationship to David Tennant. I'm sure now it will give me warm fuzzies like the thought of Tom and Lalla.
|
|
|
Post by mrfuggleboppins on Oct 28, 2015 22:26:58 GMT
- Solo stories set in the Specials Year Yes please. That would be brilliant, especially if set between The Water of Mars and The End of Time with 10 acting all Time Lord Victorious. Many of the comics set during this period have given him companions so this would actually be refreshing to see.
|
|
|
Post by CookieMaster on Oct 29, 2015 9:12:14 GMT
A few basic hopes
-The 10th Doctor meets the 5th Doctor! -An encounter with the classic Cybermen -An encounter with another Time Lord, as difficult as that would seem to be. I would just like to see(hear)his reaction. -Perhaps another meeting with Davros after 'Journey's End', if that is possible. -Reunion with John Simm's Master. This is a tough one, and nigh on impossible, something that could be more likely with the 11th Doctor. I was thinking something like the Master installing his own 'security protocol 712' after 'Utopia' in the event the Doctor regained his TARDIS. He could potentially give him and Donna the run around within the walls of his own TARDIS, playing a game of cat and mouse with them, as it were. Or, in the spirit of Halloween, a ghostly encounter with his dead enemy.
Other than that, i'm just happy 10 is joining the gang.
|
|