|
Post by slithe on Dec 21, 2019 12:05:30 GMT
A very good release... Probably one of the best EA stories that I've heard and plaudits must go to Purves and Hines for their portrayals of Hartnell and Troughton respectively. Hines has got much better over the years and it doesn't take too long to visualise Troughton saying the lines. Purves is also very good, but takes a bit longer to see him as Hartnell rather than someone 'doing a Hartnell impression'. A minor niggle, but it didn't distract from enjoyment of the story.
As has already been said, the Daleks tend to take a back seat in this one and the plot is rather thin. However, it is the First and Second Doctor meeting and Katarina being 'fleshed out' that is the highlight of this. The story captures the spirit of the era quite well and gives a hint at the terrifying power of the Time Destructor as a weapon (something often overlooked with most of the Daleks Masterplan being missing from the archives).
The sense of 'doom' surrounding Katarina is well played out and, for reasons not fully explained, she is aware of her fate even if the First Doctor and Steven are not. Whether this will be the last outing for her character is unclear - there is very limited space to develop much more with the small number of episodes she was in.
Not a bad series of the EA. Pity this one was not a bit longer - seems 2 stories is a bit of a come down. Here's hoping that there are future releases in 2020 that will be released earlier in the year to make up for the smaller episode count in 2019.
|
|
|
Post by slithe on Dec 22, 2019 11:01:24 GMT
Have just re-listened to the final episode, which I think is very strong. The contrast between the 1st and 2nd Doctors is very clear here. Despite being an 'old man' the First Doctor comes across as less mature and more stroppier/prone to rash decisions than his Second Incarnation. The gruff exterior of the First Doctor actually belies someone who is deeply fond of his companions and, whilst acknowledging the likely solution, doesn't actually want to face reality - very much like the Sixth Doctor in that respect.
The Second Doctor comes across as quite devious and callous here. The line from Jamie about this in Evil of the Daleks is very prescient and works here. He is willing to sacrifice people to save the wider universe and even tells Katrina her fate (and his part in the destruction of Troy) to score an advantage. This a far more manipulative side of the Doctor, which is not explored very often. If the First Doctor is like the Sixth, the Second comes across as far more like the Seventh - scheming and hatching plans. The 'darker' Second Doctor is on show here - a side of the character we rarely see.
Loved the line from the First Doctor about it being 'far from all over'!
|
|
|
Post by Tim Bradley on Jan 20, 2020 9:07:12 GMT
|
|
|
Post by Timelord007 on Jan 20, 2020 11:40:02 GMT
And what a fantastic review it is Mr Bradley.
|
|
|
Post by davygallagher on Jan 29, 2020 13:38:36 GMT
I absolutely adored this story.
Once the two TARDISes collided it was clear something was going wrong and it wasn't hard to figure out that Katarina was going to be the aberration of time. I liked that she herself wasn't the McGuffin though - it was nothing to do with her, it was all just the TARDIS team not going to Kembel. Very much a "Turn Left" event. Yet Katarina "sensing" that she shouldn't exist, that she was almost living on borrowed time was quite wonderful and very eerie.
I honestly think it's one of the best BF stories in a long, long time.
|
|