So I did these polls the last two years and they seemed to be popular for determining what we thought was the best of Big Finish of that year and now that it is November I've decided to get it started. Pick your top three from each month and at the end of January a top 20 pull will be compiled once polling has ended. This one is for May 2020. I'm not including any of this year's compilation rereleases as they are not produced for 2020 and excerpts are not included.
Shadow of the Sun did really show how well a remotely recorded lockdown story could be put together. Scorched Earth was well done and performed and I enjoyed the setting and the use of the companions (especially Constance). For me, however, it did drop the ball with Sixie willingly joining forces with Nazi war criminals. I did NOT care for this at all. So I think my winner for May has to be the Paternosters.
"I am a manifestation of our consciousness. I can wear what I like!!"
Paternoster Gang 3 takes the top spot for me, really enjoyed the variety of stories, even if the first one smacked you on the head a little, and the nods to the arc were better than what we eventually got. Shadow of the Sun was a pleasant little runaround for the Doctor and Leela with something to say.
The Scorched Earth was good but fell short by not being a pure historical and not being as well balanced as it should've been. It tries to show that there are innocent and guilty parties from all sides, but it does it in a very straightforward way that doesn't work in the stories favour.
The Third Doctor Adventures got stuck in a rut in Volume 5 that carried over into Volume 6. Hoping the change in TARDIS teams in 7 will give it a shake up.
For me it was between 3rd Doctor adventures and Scorched-I felt the let down of the 3rd Doc stories were the Daleks not that the script wasn’t good but after so much Time War Dalek stuff I just didn’t want another DALEK story when there is so much that can be done with the 3rd Doc and Jo and the extended family.... Scorched earth was a great tale thought provoking too and the differing opinions of the Tardis crew was well acted.So Scorched earth...has the vote
This forum is for fans of audio drama, and is not endorsed by the BBC, Big Finish, or any other organisation discussed within.
Links to our forum from other websites do not indicate our endorsement of, or cooperation with, those sites.