shutupbanks
Castellan
There’s a horror movie called Alien? That’s really offensive. No wonder everyone keeps invading you.
Likes: 5,677
|
Post by shutupbanks on Aug 8, 2023 13:02:00 GMT
Yeah, I’m not saying nobody watched it or liked it - but I’ve seen far, far more criticism of the era in numerous parts of the fanbase than I ever did any other Doctor or showrunner. It’s not just the especially vocal naysayers, either - on the doctorwho and gallifrey Reddits, there are regular posts from people who are watching the Chibnall era for the first time and really struggling to find stuff to enjoy. And in the Who threads on other forums I use, I never come across anybody who likes it, and these aren’t the hardcore fanbase likely to be haters. And the criticism is very often detailed, with major recurring issues regarding dialogue, pacing, direction, characterisation, the Doctor’s ethics. Again, I’m not saying all this to pass judgment - I’m not a massive fan, but I don’t actually hate the era either - but to ignore the fact that the era is comparatively less popular than the other new Who stuff would be sticking ones head in the sand. And earlier in the thread someone suggested that this unpopularity might make BF less likely to use Jodie’s Doctor. To which I countered that no - for those who don’t like her TV run, Big Finish will probably be seen as an opportunity for her character to be redeemed. Fair enough. As I said I my reply to Davy’s comment, my experience has been different. I really don’t see the problems raised about the Chibnall era being unique to that run of seasons, though: it’s been directed at almost every producer since the invention of fandom. I hope Jodie does come to BF also: totally in agreement there.
|
|
enofa
Full Member
Likes: 122
|
Post by enofa on Aug 8, 2023 14:50:39 GMT
True but again these are still niche areas (reddit, forums etc). Indeed - but these are the exact people who are likely be interested in Big Finish audios. The majority of casual viewers aren’t even aware our little corner of fandom even exists (sadly).
|
|